NGFW (Next-Generation Firewall) means a firewall that inspects applications, users and threats in the traffic, not only ports and IP addresses. This article compares the NGFW products of Palo Alto Networks, Fortinet and Check Point, three vendors that analysts place in the Leaders group together, on three points: core capabilities, performance and user satisfaction. It draws on analyst reports, independent test results and vendor documents. The short conclusion: all three are top-tier choices, but they differ in how they are managed, in cost over the product's life, and in test results for each model, so no single winner fits every organization.

How to read this comparison: sources and limits

The data comes from four public sources. The first is Gartner's Magic Quadrant for Hybrid Mesh Firewall, a ranking of vendors, not a product test. The second is the Forrester Wave: Enterprise Firewall Solutions from another research firm. The third is test results from CyberRatings.org, an independent testing organization that uses NSS Labs' test facility. The fourth is Gartner Peer Insights, a site that collects reviews from real users. Vendor documents add detail. DynaSec did not test the devices in its own lab. The data is a snapshot as of November 2026, and firewall software changes versions quickly, so check the original pages again before a purchase decision.

Core capabilities: the same basics, built and managed differently

All three have the core NGFW functions: application control, IPS (intrusion prevention system, which detects and blocks attacks that exploit vulnerabilities in the traffic), URL filtering, VPN (an encrypted connection over the internet), and TLS decryption (opening encrypted traffic to inspect threats hidden inside). The differences worth looking at are the architecture, the add-on subscription services and the management tools.

  • Palo Alto Networks: its PAN-OS operating system builds policy around App-ID (a technology that identifies which application the traffic belongs to, regardless of port or encryption). The vendor says App-ID is always on. Subscription add-ons include Advanced Threat Prevention (a cloud-based model that finds threats) and Advanced URL Filtering. It is managed through Panorama (a central management system for many devices) or Strata Cloud Manager (a cloud-based management system).
  • Fortinet: FortiOS is one operating system for firewall and SD-WAN work (software that chooses network paths between sites by application and link quality). Vendor documents say many models carry dedicated SPU chips (Security Processing Unit, chips that speed up inspection) to accelerate IPS and SSL decryption. Add-ons come through FortiGuard (a subscription threat-intelligence service), and management through FortiManager.
  • Check Point: the Quantum Force family uses ThreatCloud AI (a threat database that the vendor says uses more than 50 AI engines) and manages policy through SmartConsole (a central management console). Maestro (a system that joins several appliances into one group to scale capacity) is used for large deployments.
INFOGRAPHIC
Where the three brands differ
NGFW
same core functions
Palo Alto Networks
app-based policy via App-ID
Fortinet
one FortiOS + SPU chips
Check Point
ThreatCloud AI + Maestro
Management tools
Panorama · FortiManager · SmartConsole

What analysts say: three Leaders, different cautions

In Gartner's Magic Quadrant for Hybrid Mesh Firewall (vendors that sell firewalls in several forms, including appliance, virtual and cloud, under one management), media such as SDxCentral reported that Fortinet, Palo Alto Networks and Check Point were the only three Leaders in the first edition in August 2025. Media reported the same pattern for the edition dated 7 September 2026. The Forrester Wave: Enterprise Firewall Solutions for Q4 2024 also named all three as Leaders, together with Cisco, as reported by the vendors and media.

Each vendor announced its own highlights from the 2026 edition. Fortinet says it ranked highest on Ability to Execute for the second year, and Palo Alto Networks says it is positioned furthest on Completeness of Vision. Both are vendor claims. DynaSec has not read the full report. The cautions below come from the 2025 edition as summarized by SDxCentral, so read the original report for the 2026 edition.

  • Fortinet: strengths are the speed of releasing products against new threats, including quantum-resistant encryption, and FortiFlex (a flexible licensing model). The cautions, per the 2025 summary, are that customers raised concerns about product vulnerabilities and had limited visibility into the future roadmap.
  • Palo Alto Networks: strengths are the addition of AI to assess threat severity, and Strata Cloud Manager, which controls several firewall forms from one place. The cautions, per the 2025 summary, are a higher total cost than direct competitors, renewal costs high enough that some customers choose short contracts, a need for some customers to run Strata Cloud Manager alongside Panorama for at least a year before finishing the move, and reports of slow boot times and heavy resource use on the hardware.
  • Check Point: a strength is pricing transparency, as the only vendor in the report with a public pricing portal for all its products, plus flexible subscription licensing for appliances. The cautions, per the 2025 summary, are that customers reported complex initial setup and management, that it does not yet offer a firewall for containers (packaged apps that run in isolated units) or remote browser isolation (opening web pages in a separate environment to keep web malware away), and that its advanced SD-WAN is weaker than competitors.

Performance: do not compare datasheet numbers directly

The datasheets (specification documents that vendors publish) of all three list several kinds of throughput (the amount of data that can pass per second, in Gbps), such as firewall throughput, IPS throughput and threat prevention throughput. But each vendor sets its own measurement conditions, including the type of traffic, the packet size and the functions turned on during the test. The same name can therefore measure different things. Before comparing numbers, ask which functions were on and whether TLS decryption was included.

INFOGRAPHIC
Datasheet numbers vs independent tests

Vendor datasheet

  • Vendor sets the conditionstraffic type and enabled functions differ
  • Same name, different testhard to compare across brands
  • Silent on bypassno evasion results shown

Independent test

  • Same attack set for allexploits, malware and evasion
  • Protection and false positivesboth correct and wrong blocks
  • Tied to model and versiona snapshot in time

A better option is independent test results. CyberRatings.org tests firewalls with the same set of exploits, malware and evasion techniques (ways to avoid detection, such as splitting packets so the firewall cannot see the attack), and measures the protection rate, false positives (wrongly blocking normal traffic) and throughput. Its 2024 report warns that if a firewall misses even one form of evasion, an attacker may use it to bypass detection for a whole class of attacks, and that HTTPS decryption is not on by default.

The 2024 results were published on 27 June 2024 and covered models of different sizes, so they cannot be compared directly. The list shows how each model performed, nothing more.

  • Palo Alto Networks PA-450 (PAN-OS 11.1.1): Recommended, protection rate 96.36%, throughput 1,026 Mbps, price per protected Mbps $6.52
  • Fortinet FortiGate-900G (v7.4.4): Recommended, protection rate 98.21%, throughput 14,096 Mbps, price per protected Mbps $3.25
  • Check Point Quantum Force 19200 Plus (R81.20): Recommended, protection rate 98.41%, throughput 12,281 Mbps, price per protected Mbps $11.28

The 2025 results were published on 5 November 2025 under a newer test methodology, covering seven products, of which only three earned Recommended. The picture for the three vendors differs clearly from 2024, and the models tested are different again, so it cannot be read as a ranking of brands.

  • Check Point CP-CGS-9300: Recommended, security effectiveness 99.59%, false-positive accuracy 99.35%
  • Fortinet FortiGate-200G: Caution, security effectiveness 79.24%, false-positive accuracy 99.41%
  • Palo Alto Networks PA-1410: Caution, security effectiveness 46.37%, false-positive accuracy 99.66%

The testers said the weakness of Fortinet and Palo Alto Networks in that round was resisting evasion techniques. Both then submitted newer software for a retest using the same methodology and datasets, and on 25 November 2025 both moved up to Recommended. DynaSec did not find the post-retest numbers in sources it could open. This shows that a test result is a picture of one hardware model and one software version at one point in time, not a permanent score for a brand, and that software updates, including the vendor's detection signatures, may affect protection.

INFOGRAPHIC
A test result can change after a software update
01
5 Nov 2025
Caution: Fortinet, PANW
02
Fix evasion gaps
submit new builds
03
Retest
same datasets
04
25 Nov 2025
moved to Recommended

User satisfaction: very close

On Gartner Peer Insights, in the Network Firewalls market, the scores of the three vendors that we found are very close. The figures below come from summaries in search results. DynaSec could not open the original pages, so they are approximate values as of November 2026, and review counts change constantly (out of 5).

  • Fortinet: 4.6 from about 2,850 reviews; the FortiGate NGFW product is about 4.6 from roughly 2,840 reviews
  • Palo Alto Networks: 4.6 from about 1,420 reviews; the PA-Series product sits between 4.6 and 4.7 depending on when it is viewed
  • Check Point: 4.5 from about 2,170 reviews; the Quantum product is about 4.5 from roughly 1,800 reviews

A gap of 0.1 to 0.2 points is too small to decide anything. These reviews are opinions from users who chose to write them, not security tests, and they may lean toward satisfied customers. Read the review text on support, setup difficulty and renewal pricing rather than looking only at the stars.

How to choose: our view

Our view (not a conclusion from testing) is that public data is not enough to name a winner. All three are top tier, test results change by model and software, and the differences that affect a real organization usually lie in operation: team skills, cost at renewal and management tools. The ideas below are a starting point for shortlisting, not a recommendation to buy.

  • Fortinet: worth shortlisting when there are many branches and you want firewall and SD-WAN in one device (Gartner's 2025 edition, as summarized by SDxCentral, describes Fortinet as strong across network perimeter, branch and data center use), but you should have a routine for tracking vulnerability notices and applying updates.
  • Palo Alto Networks: worth shortlisting when you want detailed application-based policy and already have a familiar team, but ask for renewal prices over 3 to 5 years up front, because Gartner's 2025 edition, as summarized by SDxCentral, raises total cost.
  • Check Point: worth shortlisting when transparent pricing matters and you need to scale capacity as a group (Maestro), but allow time for initial setup and team training.

Where to start a real comparison

  • Ask for the price over the full term: have each vendor quote hardware, add-on subscriptions and renewal for 3 to 5 years in one table.
  • Set the same test conditions: turn on IPS, URL filtering, TLS decryption and logging on every brand, then measure both throughput and latency (the delay added to traffic).
  • Ask for recent independent results: ask for results for the exact model and software offered, including evasion and false positives.
  • Let your own team manage it: create policies, update software and read logs using each brand's management tools.
  • Check support in Thailand: device replacement time, local engineering team and the process for urgent vulnerability updates.

For TOR (terms of reference, the procurement scope document) writing and PoC (a real trial before the purchase decision) planning, see How to write a security TOR/RFP that gets what you need, and plan the PoC. The difference between NGFW, UTM (an all-in-one security appliance) and WAF (a firewall that protects web applications) is covered in NGFW vs UTM vs WAF: What Each One Protects, and the option of moving protection to the cloud is in SASE and SSE Explained: When Each One Fits. To assess your readiness before choosing a product, start with the readiness assessment.